Gerontius's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Zombie in City]

Thanks for the credit, mate

Love the movie. Loved the original version, too, since the dodgy subtitles made it seem like a pirated Russian film, which was cool.

Hopefully the new subtitles will stop complaints from people who don't get the joke.

[Mindy Learns a Moral]

superb

Wonderfully made, with a great animation style and some great changes in mood. Every time you thought the plot was going to get predictable it went in a new direction.

Only 9 stars though due to some average acting from some of the support phones. I didn't FEEL the bitterness :)

TmsT responds:

;_; Only the Discarded's leader was bitter... I had to cut out a lot of their subplot due to time restrictions, but it was supposed to have 287 causing a revolution as all the other discarded left with him. There were a few other scenes snipped out, too, and it left a few unxplained holes in the story, but overall it made it more suitable for folks with shorter attention spans (like Mindy)! :D

[~An Emo]

meh

Preferred the grungier quality to your previous version.

[Area 51 - Beginning]

Drawings are nice

But it's SO SOOOOO SLOOWWWWWWW. Next time, don't make a longer animation, make a shorter one with more happening.

Plus, PLEASE learn how to spell "Guard".

[Bob the Cube Part 1]

Except he's a rectangle

Cubes need a third dimension. And Bob is a silly name. Balls or birds should be called Bob. Cubes should be called Carl or something.

Anyway, it's all a bit pointless as an animation. I won't hold my breath for part 2.

[CS.SiFvsSa2C#2]

Good stuff

Some great animation touches and background work, it just felt a bit drawn out. Bit of tighter editing and more dynamic camera work could make it brilliant

[The Box...]

Good start

But needs a lot more work as it just looks unfinished at the moment. Stickmen anims can be great fun, but you have to put the effort in to create a decent story or some special catch.

[Solitary Silence]

Well drawn

Nicely done animation-wise, but as a movie it's pretty dire. Way too long, too repetitive and the audience are likely to be too dozy by the end to bother reading the message. If you wanna make a point, it needs to be snappier.